 |
|
 |
 |
Down to Earth |
 |
Based on Heaven Can Wait, the
1978 box office hit starring Warren Beatty,
Down to Earth adapts the story so that
a young black comedian is "prematurely
reincarnated" as a rich white man. Lance
Barton is a funny guy. The trouble is he’s only
funny offstage. Under the spotlight at
Harlem’s Apollo Theater, he freezes.
Repeatedly. After yet another evening of being
booed off the stage, Lance is pedaling to his
favorite comic stand for new material when
he’s distracted by an attractive woman
(Sontee). His jaw drops and his bicycle
careens into an oncoming truck. Keyes is the
angel sent to escort Lance to heaven, and
since he’s a compassionate supernatural
being, he transports Lance out of his body a
split second before the inevitable collision.
Problem #1: As it turns out, the accident
wouldn’t have killed Lance. So now he’s in
heaven approximately 43 years before his
time.
Problem #2: Lance’s body has already
been discovered, so he can’t return to Earth
as himself. But the angels are willing to send
him back in someone else’s body, provided
that person’s death hasn’t yet been
discovered. Enter Charles Wellington, the 15th
richest man in America, a heartless business
tycoon whose cheating wife and personal
assistant have plotted to kill him. A poisoned
Wellington lies dead in his bathtub, making
his body available for immediate occupancy.
At first, Lance doesn’t want anything to do with
Wellington’s corpse ("I can’t be funny in that
body!"). Then he discovers that assuming
Wellington’s identity will give him a shot at
Sontee, so he strikes a deal with the angels to
inhabit the body temporarily. But will his
aged white body and youthful black humor be
enough to win over the audience at the
Apollo? And what about winning the heart of
Sontee?
•
positive elements: Amidst the film’s
dubious theology, the true message is
repeated that everything is part of a
grand plan. Also reinforced is the idea that a
person’s soul—not his body—is what’s really
important to his identity. Sontee tells Lance,
"It’s not all about looks." In fact, this is the
biggest lesson he learns: People too often
judge others by their looks, but what really
matters is what’s on the inside.
In Wellington’s body, Lance has a unique
perspective on race and class inequality. In
essence, he’s a privileged person who truly
understands how the underprivileged live. As
such, he gives his house staff the royal
treatment, urging his accent-faking butler to be
himself and turning everyone’s expectations
upside-down by serving his servants. Sontee
is a wise woman with genuine concern for the
poor. Lance takes her advice to "do something
positive with your money," giving cash to a
bum on the street and making other unselfish
gestures. And though his interest in Sontee
begins as a purely physical attraction, Lance
ends up genuinely wanting to help her
cause—protecting the public status of the
urban hospital Wellington had wanted to buy
out and privatize.
Lance’s marriage proposal to Sontee
reinforces the relevance and value of the
institution, rather than making sex or
cohabitation the end-all-be-all of
relationships.
•
spiritual content: Down to
Earth means well but takes huge
theological liberties. On one hand, the film
acknowledges that there is indeed life after
death, that a physical heaven and hell exist
and that "it is appointed for man once to die."
But is it really possible for a man to end up in
heaven before he’s actually dead? Down to
Earth’s answer to spiritual questions
seems to be that the supernatural world is not
all that different from the natural one. Angels
make mistakes. Big ones. And they feel
obliged to "make it up to" the humans they’ve
wronged. They can be carnal (A doorman
ogles beautiful women), capricious (Keyes
flippantly tells someone to "go to hell") and
boastful (Mr. King says, "I’m a friggin’ angel, I
can do whatever I want"). Heaven is not much
more than the perfect dance club. ("The food
is great, the women are beautiful, the music is
hot and the fun never stops.") Also,
reincarnation is central to the story line. And
the fact that God is barely given a mention,
even in heaven, is telling of the way the
characters live on earth—they just don’t think
He matters in everyday life.
•
sexual content: Sontee is a strong
and uncompromising character—her
determination to save the hospital keeps her
from being quickly swayed by
Lance/Wellington’s advances. Their
relationship remains mostly respectful and
innocent. Even more impressive is that
Lance’s comedy routine is fairly clean, though
a few mild sexual references do slip in here
and there. (How few is amazing,
considering actor Chris Rock’s real-life track
record).
On the other hand, Mrs. Wellington’s
adulterous relationship with Sklar (not to
mention her immodest wardrobe) is
disgusting. They’re hardly ashamed of being
found in bed together. He’s often got his hand
up her skirt, and their "sweet talk" to each
other is almost always sadomasochistic. The
writers and directors obviously mean for this
to be viewed as a "dirty" relationship, but that
doesn’t excuse the overt innuendo and
onscreen foreplay. Then, to make matters
worse, Lance gives Sklar permission to
continue the illicit affair as he pursues other
women. When Lance (as Wellington) admits
that he loves Sontee and that he wants to
divorce his wife, Mrs. Wellington tries to get
him back by seducing him in numerous ways,
including inviting him to join the ménage à
trois he’s always fantasized about. Also,
Lance briefly watches The Playboy
Channel.
•
violent content: Lance hits Keyes
when he finds out that the angel took his soul
prematurely. When Mr. King takes Lance "body
shopping," they visit several characters just
before their deaths. Nothing is graphic, but,
disturbingly, the situations are supposed to be
humorous (a man leaps from a window, an
old jogger has a heart attack and barbells fall
on a weightlifter’s throat). Lance gets punched
by a thug in a diner for using ethnic slang
"reserved" for African-Americans, and he
accidentally hits Sklar in the face with a golf
club. Shots are fired at a rap concert and a
resulting death is implied. A sniper is shown
with his rifle just before a kill, but the actual
murder is not shown.
•
crude or profane language: Almost
too many to count. Constant use of a--. About
a dozen s-words. Two bleeped or muffled
f-words. Gangsta rap in the background also
incorporates swearing. There are a few
inappropriate uses of God’s name and one
obscene gesture.
•
drug and alcohol content: Many
characters are shown drinking alcohol,
including people in heaven. Two smoke,
including an angel. Mrs. Wellington is
excessively fond of cocktails. Lance asks
Sklar, "Was I takin’ Ecstasy that day?" The
Snoop-Dogg assisted soundtrack includes
repeated references to indo [marijuana] and
gin ‘n juice. There’s a crack about the devil
having "good weed."
•
other negative elements: Though it is
clear to the audience that Lance never made a
marriage commitment to Mrs. Wellington, he
is living in the body of someone who
did, so the fact that he takes divorce so lightly
is disconcerting.
•
conclusion: Playing the true-to-life
role of a stand-up comic, Rock is in his
element. Through Lance’s struggle to be
funny, he gets to explore the ins and outs of
his "art"—taking real life situations and
depicting them in a way that throws the
audience off guard. With race and class
differences as his subject, he’s very effective,
not to mention truly funny. And Wellington’s
body makes him even more so (an insightful
look at the double-standard applied to some
racial slurs and subject matter—the same
words can be perceived very differently
depending on the source).
It’s the comedy that arguably makes this
film work better than its 1978
predecessor. Too bad the same can’t be said
for the content. Rock recently told TV Guide
that he had hoped for a PG rating for
Down to Earth. "[Paramount] thought I
was crazy," he says, "but it’s Heaven Can
Wait. Why should it be an R? I don’t even
know how it got to [be] PG-13. This is a real
clean movie; I think parents are real happy
when they can take their kids to see the
‘cursing guy.’" Kudos to Rock for wanting to
keep Down to Earth as family-friendly
as the original. Unfortunately, he failed. The
addition of sexual humor, foul language and
drug and alcohol references keep those
hopes earthbound. Down to Earth may
be a step in the right direction for Rock, but the
"cursing guy" will have to keep trying if his goal
is a true family film.
|
 |